Can You Save Pacifiers for the Next Baby: Safety and Storage Tips

Last Update:

Can You Save Pacifiers for the Next Baby

When expecting a second child, parents often wonder if it’s possible to reuse certain items from their first baby, such as pacifiers. The idea of reusing pacifiers may seem both cost-effective and environmentally friendly, but there are important factors to consider regarding safety and health.

Generally, it is not recommended to save pacifiers for the next baby, as they can wear down and deteriorate with time. The materials used in pacifiers can break down, posing a potential choking hazard for the baby. Additionally, storing and reusing pacifiers may lead to contamination, which could negatively impact the baby’s health.

When choosing pacifiers for a newborn, it is essential to prioritize the baby’s safety and well-being. Parents should invest in new pacifiers that are age-appropriate and meet safety standards. This ensures that the baby has access to a clean, safe, and properly functioning pacifier to meet their soothing needs.

Can You Save Pacifiers for the Next Baby

When it comes to preparing for a new baby, parents often wonder if they can reuse certain items from their previous child. One such item that is commonly questioned is the pacifier. The primary concern when considering whether pacifiers can be saved for the next child revolves around safety and hygiene.

It is generally advised against saving pacifiers for your second baby, as they can wear with time. Pacifier materials, such as rubber or silicone, are likely to break down over time, posing a choking hazard to the baby. Additionally, older pacifiers may no longer meet the most recent safety standards.

Another concern is sanitation, as used pacifiers may contain microbes that are hard to remove even after sterilization. Babies have delicate immune systems, making it important to minimize their exposure to such contaminants. Purchasing new pacifiers for your second baby helps ensure the cleanliness and safety of the product.

Here are some additional reasons to buy new pacifiers:

  • Frequent use can cause pacifiers to lose their shape, potentially affecting a baby’s oral development
  • There might be updates in design or materials to improve safety and comfort
  • Newborn and older baby pacifiers are often designed differently to accommodate their age-specific needs

In conclusion, while it may seem economical to save pacifiers for your next child, the potential risks to safety and sanitation far outweigh the benefits. For peace of mind and optimal health, it is best to invest in new pacifiers for each baby.

Can You Save Pacifiers for the Next Baby

Pacifier Hygiene and Safety

Cleaning and Sterilization

Pacifier hygiene is crucial to ensure your baby’s safety and health. Make sure to wash and sterilize the pacifier regularly, especially for newborns under three months old, who may require daily sterilization. Use warm water and mild soap for regular cleaning, and consider using a dishwasher-safe variety to simplify the sterilization process.

Pacifier Lifespan

Over time, pacifiers may wear down and become less safe for your baby. Regular exposure to high temperatures during sterilization can cause the nipple to deteriorate faster. Be mindful of the pacifier’s condition, and inspect it for any signs of wear or damage. Replace the pacifier if you notice any cracking or thinning of the nipple material. Avoid using expired, damaged or worn-out pacifiers for your next baby, as they can pose a choking hazard or become less effective at soothing your child.

Pacifier Storage

To maintain proper pacifier hygiene, store them in a clean, dry place when not in use. Avoid keeping pacifiers in potentially dirty or damp areas, such as diaper bags or pockets. Instead, opt for a designated pacifier case or container that can protect the pacifier from contaminants. This ensures that your baby’s pacifier remains clean and safe until it’s needed.

When to Replace Pacifiers

Pacifiers can provide great comfort to infants, but they do not last forever. It is essential to replace them on a regular basis to ensure they remain safe and effective for your little one.

Typically, pacifiers should be replaced after your baby reaches six months of age. This is because older babies will require pacifiers that are specifically designed for their age group. These pacifiers have soft nipples and are dishwasher-safe, making them easier to clean and maintain. It is also crucial to choose a pacifier with a shield that measures at least 1 1/4 inches or larger, as this helps to prevent choking hazards. The shield must also have holes for proper ventilation.

Regardless of your baby’s age, it is recommended to inspect the pacifier regularly for signs of wear and tear. This includes looking for cracks, discoloration, or thinning of the nipple material. If any of these signs are present, it is time to replace the pacifier immediately.

Furthermore, pacifiers should not be reused with a second baby. The reason behind this is that the constant use and cleaning of pacifiers can cause them to degrade in quality over time. This wear and tear might lead to choking hazards or other risks for your next child. Instead, it is a good idea to purchase new pacifiers for each baby to ensure their safety.

Pacifier Material Differences

Understanding the differences between pacifier materials is crucial for parents when deciding whether to reuse a pacifier for their next baby.


Silicone pacifiers are a popular choice for many parents due to their durability and ease of cleaning. This material is resistant to heat and does not retain odors or taste. Silicone pacifiers tend to last longer than their latex counterparts, but they can still break down over time.

Although silicone is less likely to develop cracks and tears compared to latex, used pacifiers may still pose a choking hazard as the material becomes weaker with time, use, and exposure to heat. It’s recommended to replace silicone pacifiers every 4-6 weeks for safety reasons.


Latex pacifiers are made from natural rubber and offer a softer, more flexible option than silicone. Some parents find that their babies prefer the texture of latex pacifiers over silicone ones. However, latex is more prone to degradation and may need to be replaced more frequently.

Over time, latex pacifiers can develop cracks and other signs of wear, which can present a choking hazard to babies. Additionally, this material can cause allergic reactions in some individuals. It’s essential to inspect and replace latex pacifiers regularly to ensure they remain safe for use.

In conclusion, both silicone and latex pacifiers degrade over time, posing potential safety risks to babies. Parents should always purchase new pacifiers for their next child to maintain safety and hygiene.

Can You Save Pacifiers for the Next Baby

Reasons to Consider New Pacifiers

When expecting a new baby, it’s essential to prioritize their safety and health. One item that parents often consider reusing is pacifiers; however, there are several reasons to purchase new ones instead of reusing older ones from a previous child.

Firstly, pacifier materials deteriorate over time. The silicone or latex used in pacifiers can break down, increasing the risk of potential choking hazards. This deterioration might be caused by general wear and tear or exposure to heat, sunlight, or the rigors of everyday use. Even if the pacifier looks intact, the weakened material can pose a risk.

Secondly, contamination is a concern. While pacifiers can be thoroughly cleaned, bacteria and mold can still accumulate over time, which may not be visible to the naked eye. Introducing a new baby to these hidden contaminants may lead to health issues.

Lastly, advances in pacifier technology and safety may have occurred since the older pacifier was purchased. Newer models might offer added security features or improved designs that are more beneficial to your baby’s well-being.

In summary, while it might be tempting to reuse pacifiers for a second baby, the potential risks outweigh the benefits. Purchasing new pacifiers ensures that you’re providing the safest and most up-to-date options for your new bundle of joy.


In summary, it is not recommended to save pacifiers for the next baby. This is due to the fact that the pacifier material can wear and break down over time, posing a potential choking hazard for the baby. Additionally, pacifiers may become contaminated, posing a risk to the baby’s health.

It is essential to prioritize safety and hygiene when it comes to baby products, particularly when it comes to items like pacifiers. Newer models of pacifiers are designed with improved orthodontic support and are easier to clean, often being dishwasher or microwave safe.

To further ensure the wellbeing of your child, it’s advisable to follow the recommended guidelines for pacifier usage, including replacing them periodically and choosing the appropriate size for your baby’s age. Remember that while pacifiers can offer benefits, such as reducing the risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), proper care and use are crucial.

Photo of author


My name is Catherine. I'm a Mom and one of the avid writers working on HerScoop!