Orthodontic Pacifier Vs Soothie

Last Update:

Orthodontic Pacifier Vs Soothie

Sometimes it seems like your baby is crying just to annoy you. The little singer can’t stop but there is a solution – its majesty – pacifier. The question is orthodontic or soothie pacifier? Let’s compare and see the difference between an orthodontic pacifier vs soothie.

Orthodontic pacifiers are usually composed of several parts of the handrail, shield, and nipple. The nipple is flattened and has an anatomical shape that protects your baby’s palate and jaw so that the teeth do not bend. Many fear that some part of the orthodontic pacifier may break off and the baby may swallow or suffocate but that’s less likely.

Soothie is a type of pacifier cast in one piece, usually made of silicone rather than latex, that usually helps babies to erupt teeth. It is very popular and has no components where impurities can remain. It is soft and there are no small parts that can break off. The nipple is most reminiscent of a mother’s breast and babies easily accept it. 

The baby will choose the one that suits its needs the best, but never allow the baby to use the pacifier for a long time. Weaning a baby from a pacifier should start at six to eight months. If you don’t do it on time, you will have problems later, and it will be harder to get rid of them.

The pacifier serves to calm your baby when it is nervous when teeth are growing, or even when it has stomach cramps. Simply when babies have a bad day/time. The baby is soothed by sucking the pacifier because it satisfies its natural urge to suck.

What is a soothie pacifier?

Soothie pacifier is a type of pacifier that is quite popular, i.e. parents often buy it because babies accept them with ease. The best pacifier is the one your baby accepts, so be prepared to throw in a few pacifiers until you find the right one.

Soothie pacifiers are made of one piece of silicone, usually soft and pleasant in contact with the skin. They are easy to maintain, which is very important for hygiene because the baby puts them in the mouth. There are no components and cracks where dirt can remain. It is easily sterilized and used in maternity hospitals to soothe newborns. 

There are also soothies that are extra soft and are good when your baby’s teeth start to erupt. The baby is then especially nervous and bites the pacifier, which due to its smooth texture cannot hurt the baby’s gums. 

The most important thing is a satisfied baby, so it is always good to have more pacifiers as a reserve. That way, the baby will be calm and you will not have a headache.

What is the best pacifier for newborns?

Orthodontic Pacifier Vs Soothie

The best pacifiers for a newborn are small silicone ones, with a nipple that resembles a mother’s breast. They are cylindrical in shape and are used in the first three months of a baby’s life. Some experts do not recommend the use of pacifiers in the first month of the baby’s life until the baby gets used to breastfeeding.

Some parents are against pacifiers, because it’s difficult to get rid of, and they are not healthy in the later period of the baby’s life. But when a healthy baby needs to calm down, its teeth are growing or it is nervous, then a pacifier can be a lifesaver. Perhaps the soothie pacifier is best for your newborn because of its sleek texture and softness.

Later, in the period from three to six months, you should switch to orthodontic pacifiers. An orthodontic pacifier protects your baby’s palate and prevents teeth and jaws from curling. The nipple of the orthodontic pacifier is flattened and follows the curvature of the palate. They are usually made of rubber or silicone.

After the sixth month, it is best to start weaning the baby from the pacifier. But if the baby cannot do without pacifiers, use orthodontics, and if necessary, consult a pediatrician on how to wean the baby off the pacifier.

Is the Philips Avent soothie pacifier safe?

Yes, they are safe. These are some of the better pacifiers available on the market. They are made of silicone, do not contain harmful substances, and they have holes on the shield as openings for air, so they cannot close the baby’s airways. 

The shield is the right size so that the baby cannot suck the pacifier and cause suffocation. The nipple is solidly done, anatomically, and resembles a mother’s breast. They do not use a handrail – a ring on the shield, but a small tab, so the baby cannot hook the pacifier with its fingers and pull it out.

Philips Avent soothie pacifiers are used in neonatal hospitals because they are safe, easy to maintain, and accepted by babies. These pacifiers are not expensive, they last a long time, they are produced in various cheerful colors, and they are recommended by many institutions and pediatricians.

What are the pros and cons of orthodontic pacifiers?

Orthodontic Pacifier Vs Soothie

Pros of orthodontic pacifiers are that they are good, mostly safe pacifiers. They have an anatomical nipple that protects the palate and protects the jaw to prevent crooked teeth. That is why pediatricians recommend them and suggest that babies switch to orthodontic pacifiers when they are three months old. 

In the period from three to six months, the baby should switch to an orthodontic pacifier, because the nipple of the orthodontic pacifier is curved and follows the anatomical shape of the palate. 

Cons of orthodontic pacifiers: Some parents are afraid of orthodontic pacifiers because they consist of several parts that can burst and a part that can be swallowed by a baby. That is unlikely but not impossible. 

A pacifier made of several parts can retain impurities in these compositions. It’s a little harder to maintain. And in the end, like any other pacifier, orthodontics creates a habit in babies. Sometimes it is very difficult to wean a baby from a pacifier and parents have problems. 

It is not good for your baby to use a pacifier for a long time, there is a danger of crooked teeth, ear infections, and the possibility of a large number of infections. Toddlers in that period saw everything as objects for play and even pacifiers. That is why you need to avoid giving your baby a pacifier from the age of six months and start weaning.


Orthodontic pacifier vs soothie, which one to choose, which one is the best for your muffin? Let’s wrap it up. Orthodontic pacifiers typically consist of several parts, such as the handrail, shield, and nipple. In addition to being flattened and having an anatomical shape, the nipple of the pacifier protects the baby’s palate and jaw. 

Soothie is a type of pacifier made of silicone, cast in one piece, that enables babies to erupt their teeth. Unlike other types of pacifiers, it does not contain any components that could harbor impurities. The nipple on the soothie most closely resembles a mother’s breast, and babies readily accept it. 

In the end, it’s not important whether parents prefer one pacifier or another because the baby is the one that will make a decision. It will choose the pacifier that is most comfortable and suitable to its needs. 

Photo of author


My name is Catherine. I'm a Mom and one of the avid writers working on HerScoop!