When to Change Pacifier Size: Expert Guidelines for Your Baby’s Comfort

Last Update:

When to Change Pacifier Size

When it comes to caring for a growing baby, one aspect parents often have questions about is when to change the size of their child’s pacifier. As babies grow and develop, it’s essential to adjust the pacifier size to ensure their safety and comfort. Although some parents might not even realize that they need to make changes, it is an important consideration for their baby’s well-being.

Pacifiers typically come in three size options based on age: 0-6 months, 6-18 months, and 18+ months. Experts recommend waiting to introduce a pacifier until the baby is comfortable with breastfeeding, which is usually around three or four weeks after birth. The initial pacifier size would then normally be for newborns to 3 or 6 months old. As the baby grows, it is important to monitor the pacifier’s condition and adjust the size accordingly, ensuring it remains appropriate for the child’s age and needs.

Matching the pacifier size and shape to your baby’s age and needs can help prevent potential hazards and improve comfort. Signs that it’s time to switch to a larger pacifier size include excessive wear and tear, deterioration, or if the pacifier seems too small for your baby’s mouth. Upgrading to the correct size not only maintains safety but also encourages proper oral development and reduces the likelihood of dental issues later in life.

Recognizing the Need for a Change

Age and Development Guidelines

It is essential to choose the appropriate pacifier size based on your baby’s age and developmental stage. Generally, pacifiers are categorized into three sizes: small (for 0-6 months), medium (for 6-18 months), and large (for 18+ months). These age ranges serve as a reference point for identifying when your baby may need to transition to the next pacifier size.

However, each child’s growth and development may vary. So, it’s crucial to observe your baby closely and adjust the pacifier size accordingly.

Signs of Discomfort

In addition to adhering to the age and development guidelines for pacifier sizes, parents should also watch for signs that their baby is experiencing discomfort with their current pacifier. These signs may indicate that it’s time to change to a larger size:

  • Your baby frequently spits out the pacifier or struggles to keep it in their mouth.
  • The pacifier leaves marks or irritations around your baby’s mouth.
  • Your baby shows signs of difficulty in breathing while using the pacifier.

Another critical aspect to consider is the mouth shield’s size on the pacifier. If the mouth shield is the same size or smaller than the baby’s mouth, it’s time to move up a size to reduce any risk of choking.

When to Change Pacifier Size

Choosing the Right Pacifier Size

It is essential to choose the right pacifier size for your baby, as different sizes cater to specific age ranges and developmental stages. This section discusses size guidelines by brand, pacifier materials, and shapes to help you make an informed decision.

Size Guidelines by Brand

Though size guidelines might vary slightly among different brands, most pacifiers have three standard size options based on age:

  • 0-6 months
  • 6-18 months
  • 18+ months

It’s crucial to follow the manufacturer’s recommendations to ensure your baby uses a pacifier that is safe and age-appropriate. However, keep in mind that age is only a general guideline, and your baby’s preference might vary. Some brands offer more specific size recommendations:

  • BIBS: Onesize (0+ months), Size 1 (0+ months), Size 2 (6+ months), and Size 3 (18+ months)

Pacifier Materials and Shapes

Beyond size, pacifiers come in a variety of materials and shapes. It’s essential to select a pacifier tailored to your baby’s age, preferences, and needs. Popular materials include:

  • Latex: Soft, natural, and biodegradable
  • Silicone: Hypoallergenic, durable, and easy to clean

As for shapes, pacifiers generally come in four distinct categories:

  • Cylindrical
  • Cherry
  • Butterfly
  • Orthodontic

Each pacifier shape comes with its own advantages and disadvantages. For instance, cylindrical pacifiers usually offer a universal fit for babies, while cherry-shaped pacifiers provide better oral stimulation. Butterfly pacifiers allow room for the nose and cheeks, and orthodontic pacifiers are designed to encourage proper jaw development.

Matching the pacifier size, material, and shape to your baby’s age and needs will help ensure comfort and safety as they grow and develop. It’s essential to monitor your baby’s growth and replace or size up the pacifier when appropriate, considering any visible signs of wear and other factors like cleanliness.

Safety Considerations

When managing pacifier use for your baby, safety is paramount. This includes assessing when to change the pacifier size and ensuring the pacifier is always in good condition. In this section, we will discuss inspecting the pacifier for damage, and proper cleaning and storage practices.

Inspecting the Pacifier for Damage

Regularly checking the pacifier for any signs of damage is essential to prevent any choking hazards. Look for cracks, tears, or weak areas in the silicone or rubber, especially in the nipple section. If you notice any of these issues, it’s time to replace the pacifier with a new one.

Also, observe the pacifier’s size recommendations on the packaging (e.g., 0-3 months, 0-6 months, 6-18 months, etc.). As your baby grows, ensure the pacifier size remains appropriate for their age and development level.

Proper Cleaning and Storage

Maintaining optimal hygiene and cleanliness for your baby’s pacifier ensures their health and safety. Follow these guidelines for cleaning pacifiers:

  • Before first use, follow the manufacturer’s instructions for sterilizing the pacifier.
  • Wash the pacifier regularly with hot soapy water and rinse it thoroughly to keep it free from germs. If the pacifier is dishwasher safe, this can also be an effective cleaning method.
  • Replace the pacifier when it shows visible signs of wear or after a certain period of use, as recommended by the manufacturer.

Store pacifiers in a clean, dry place when not in use. Avoid exposing them to direct sunlight, as this can degrade the materials. Proper storage can also help extend the life of the pacifier and ensure it remains safe for your baby to use.

Transitioning to a Larger Size

It is essential to recognize the signs that your baby is ready for a larger pacifier size. Transitioning to a larger size can be done by introducing the new size and phasing out the old size gradually.

Introducing the New Size

When your baby is nearing the end of the age range for the current pacifier or if the mouth shield is the same size or smaller than your baby’s mouth, it is time to introduce a larger size. Offer the new, larger pacifier during a calm and familiar routine, such as after feeding or before bedtime. It may take some time for your baby to adjust to the new size, so be patient and persistent.

Size Age Range
Size 1 0-6 months
Size 2 6-18 months
Size 3, 4, and 5 18 months – 3 years

When to Change Pacifier Size

Phasing Out the Old Size

As your baby becomes more comfortable with the new larger pacifier, gradually phase out the use of the smaller size. For instance, you could start by only offering the larger size at specific times, such as during naps or bedtime, and then gradually increase its use throughout the day.

  • Begin by offering the larger size during a specific routine, such as naptime.
  • Gradually increase the use of the larger size throughout the day as your baby becomes more accustomed to it.
  • Monitor your baby for any signs of discomfort or difficulty in using the new pacifier size and adjust accordingly.

Remember that each baby is unique, and some may take longer than others to adapt to the larger pacifier size. Be patient, supportive, and flexible during the transition process.

When to Stop Using a Pacifier

Dental and Speech Concerns

It is generally recommended to stop using a pacifier by the time your child turns 2 years old. According to the American Dental Association, prolonged pacifier use between the ages of 2 and 4 can cause issues with the growth of the mouth, teeth alignment, and permanent changes in the palate.

Before the age of two, any dental issues caused by pacifier usage are likely to be insignificant and self-resolving within approximately six months after stopping pacifier use.

Child Readiness

It is necessary to consider your child’s readiness to stop using a pacifier. Some children may show signs of readiness earlier than others, such as less interest in the pacifier, or easily giving it up for other forms of comfort.

If your child is older than the recommended age, it is advisable to wean them off the pacifier. Starting around six months of age, you can gradually reduce the amount of time your child uses the pacifier. This weaning process does not mean taking the pacifier away completely, but instead helping your child rely on it less.

Photo of author


My name is Catherine. I'm a Mom and one of the avid writers working on HerScoop!